Getting the Deal Done Early


Back in June, my former day-job asked to come out of retirement and help out for a couple of months. Contrary to what I was told then – here we are in November and I’m still helping out. Fortunately, I (supposedly) will go back into full retirement after Nov 30.

I say that because Wednesday morning was very hectic at work – so hectic that I was not able to check social media at all. Sometime around mid-morning, I got a text from an IndyCar group-chat I am in simply saying “Wasn’t expecting a Newgarden contract extension announcement today”. I had heard nothing about it, but the text was pretty self-explanatory in what it was talking about.

I’ll be honest, I was more than a little shocked. In my mind, there were three possible scenarios regarding Josef Newgarden’s contract, which was set to expire at the end of the 2027 season – re-sign with Team Penske, sign with another team or retire.

For the past three years, I have found myself walking on egg shells any time I write about fellow-Nashvillian Josef Newgarden. He was the topic of an article that landed me in the IndyCar doghouse, that I’ve not fully gotten out of. What got me in hot-water was commenting on IndyCar’s marketing efforts within the article, but Newgarden was the topic of that article and I’ve always been a little skittish writing about him since then.

Of the three possible scenarios regarding Josef Newgarden and his contract status, I thought Newgarden was headed toward retirement following the 2027 season. He just didn’t look like or sound like a driver who was having any fun.

Things have not gone well for Newgarden at Team Penske for the past two or three seasons. Winning his second consecutive Indianapolis 500 was about the only highlight of Newgarden’s 2024 season. Yes, he won at Gateway, but he was also disqualified from his win at St. Petersburg and had to deal with the public-relations fallout from that.

For me, that was the turning point in Newgarden’s public demeanor. Gone were the fun-loving days of witty banter with teammate Scott McLaughlin on their Bus Bros podcast and apparently their good-hearted relationship. They became strictly teammates as Newgarden chose to focus solely on his driving.

The 2025 season was a nightmare for Newgarden. He and teammate Will Power were moved to the back of the starting grid for the Indianapolis 500, after Team Penske was found to be using altered attenuators. Key people were fired from Team Penske, including his close friend and president of Team Penske, Tim Cindric. After the departure of important people in management, Team Penske struggled for the remainder of the 2025 season. On top of that, Newgarden went through one of the worst stretches of sheer bad luck that I’ve ever seen a driver go through. A perfect example is the race at Gateway. On Lap 130, Newgarden was leading and had already led 25 laps. He seemed to be in total control, when out of nowhere – Louis Foster hit the outside wall, shot across the track and collected Newgarden, who flipped over on the main straightaway. That typified the 2025 season for Newgarden.

Things seemed to turn around at the season finale at Nashville, where Newgarden led 60 laps and cruised to a win in his hometown. You would’ve thought he would have been ecstatic to finally win a race in Nashville on his fifth try. Instead, he felt nothing but relief – not to finally get the win, but to put the 2025 season – a season where he finished twelfth in points – to an end and out of its misery.

This past season was better. Newgarden finished seventh at St. Petersburg, and he won at Phoenix – briefly putting him in first place after two races. The next three races were road and street courses that saw Newgarden finish no better than tenth. He finished fourth on the IMS road course, but had a disappointing twenty-second place finish in the 500, where he crashed and suffered a leg injury that plagued him throughout most of the rest of the season. He gave a gutsy performance at Detroit, finishing tenth on a rough street circuit that demands a lot of heavy braking. He followed that up with a win at Gateway.

By this time, Newgarden had grown tired of answering questions about his leg. When asked direct questions pertaining to him having to change his braking foot, instead of simply answering the questions – he responded with nonsensical answers that had nothing to do with the questions asked. Sometimes he was so surly with the FOX pit-reporters, he seemed to be channeling his inner Bill Belechick by giving one-word responses. I’ve been told the FOX reporters groaned when they were assigned to Newgarden’s pit for the weekend.

The exuberant and enthusiastic 20-year-old kid I interviewed in 2011 was gone. There seemed to be nothing left but a grumpy middle-aged man who was not having any fun at all.

Newgarden looked and sounded miserable to me. I figured he either had his eye on retirement once his contract was up, or he would entertain offers from other teams throughout the 2027 season. As usual, I was wrong.

Wednesday morning, Team President Jonathan Diuguid announced that Newgarden had signed a new multiyear deal that will position Newgarden and the team for the future.

I’m glad this has happened when it did, and I think this is good for all parties involved. Team Penske gets to keep their long-tenured driver who has been with the team for over a decade. He is a sponsors dream that comes across as genuine and polished in-person as well as on TV. He has won two championships for Team Penske, but more important to the team – he has two Indianapolis 500 victories under the Team Penske banner.

I felt like the team bungled the Will Power contract negotiations in 2025. That was when there was a leadership void in a very unsettled atmosphere. Now that things have settled down, you get the idea that they didn’t want to let another champion and 500-winner get away. Good for them for learning from their mistake.

Perhaps Newgarden was so surly because he had a front-row seat to how the Power negotiations had failed, and how strange it was to see his longtime teammate driving for another team. Maybe he was afraid he was going to suffer the same fate when contract time rolled around for him. You certainly couldn’t blame him if that was the case.

I follow the rule that Change is Bad. After a year of seeing Will Power in an Andretti car, I still don’t like it. Nothing against Andretti Global or the fine people there, but Power had earned the right to finish out his career at Team Penske. I didn’t like seeing Johnny Unitas wearing a Chargers uniform, or Peyton Manning as a Bronco. Will Power should have finished out his career at Team Penske.

It looks like Josef Newgarden will now get the chance to do just that. Diuguid did not specify how many years the contract was. Newgarden with turn 36 next month. Assuming it was your standard three-year deal, he will be in his late 30s when this deal is up.

I am hopeful that Team Penske and Josef Newgarden can regain their form that saw them both enjoy so much success not that long ago. Newgarden is still in the prime of his career. I am guessing that his best season ever still lies ahead of him where he dominates races, wins the championship and the Indianapolis 500 all in the same season. Now that he has settled his new contract before Christmas, he can focus on what needs to be done to unseat the reign of Alex Palou. He is probably the most likely to do it.

George Phillips

8 Responses to “Getting the Deal Done Early”

  1. Joseph Mudrak's avatar
    Joseph Mudrak Says:

    Re: Will Power. Millions of people would like to finish their career with a long term employer, but the employer has different priorities.. Why should athletes not be subject to the same fate?

  2. I would love to read the article that got you in trouble with Indy Car. Could you please post a link.

  3. He is my least favorite driver and a cheater. I wish he would have retired!

  4. Bruce Waine's avatar
    Bruce Waine Says:

    All of which brings to mind that we (the public / spectators) are not privy to the behind the scenes activity that motivated Josef to all of a sudden put on a happy face and continue with Team Penske.

    Indeed, there is evidently / apparently more to this than has been released to news outlets and only leads to more speculation.

    Josef deeply ( aka very deeply ) appeared publicly ( out of character for a Team Penske driver) not happy or content (with the team ? ? ) in 2026.

    Game over in other words

    Two speculative opinons.

    Where is Tom Cindric in this story and was Tim or is Tim a factor in josef’s reupping with Team Penske ?

    Similar question ….. Where is Malukas in this story and was Malukas or is Malukas a factor ? ?

    Etc……………………..

    Yoour opinion next?

    • Team Penske doesn’t really have leaks. Billionaires tend to only hire the scabbiest of people who don’t talk. We will probably never know.

  5. billytheskink's avatar
    billytheskink Says:

    Good for Josef, I hope he performs well. The series is at its best when it is at its most competitive, and Newgarden has the track record and the seat to make things more competitive.

Leave a Reply