Random Thoughts on Nashville
Greetings from Vanderbilt University Medical Center! After a day at the track and writing a post-race re-cap, I packed up my stuff and headed west to visit with Susan in the hospital and write my Random Thoughts. This may be more brief than usual, but please understand why. Susan is still doing very well, and will most likely go home Monday. Fingers crossed.
Looking back at the race, it was an odd race. I suppose it was because the championship battle never materialized and was over after 12 laps. I don’t know if I would classify the race as processional, but there were not a ton of passes near the front – especially in the first half. Altogether, there were three cautions, and two of them were in the first half. All three cautions were single car incidents.
The bulk of the action came in the last thirty to forty laps of the race. One by one, the leaders would drop out, making you wonder just who would win the race. No matter how much passing there is, it’s always intriguing when you have no idea who is going to win as you approach the end of any race.
As I said yesterday, I always feel a little sad for the race winner in the season finale, because they never get the full attention that a race winner should – so much attention is paid to crowning the champion. I would really feel sorry for a first-time winner that won a race that features a championship battle. Late in the race, I wondered if we would be celebrating David Malukas getting his first win as he closed out his brief career with Meyer Shank Racing. That would have been awkward.
But in the end, it was Colton Herta earning his first career oval win with a brilliant late-race pass on Pato O’Ward, and Alex Palou winning his third championship in four years. It’s hard to believe that he already has half as many championships as Scott Dixon, and he’s only twenty-seven. You wonder if we are witnessing the early career of one of the best ever. Congratulations to both Herta and Palou on a very successful weekend.
TV Coverage: Obviously I’ve not seen any of the coverage, but I wanted to express my thanks to this TV crew that has been coming into our living rooms since 2009. I will miss them, and I hope as many as possible will make the transition to FOX – now that NBC has officially signed off.
Local Winner: In past years, if you had said that a local driver won the Music City Grand Prix – most would have guessed that Josef Newgarden had won his hometown race. When this event was first announced in 2020, Josef Newgarden was part of the announcement. You could tell that the first race was circled on his calendar, and he really wanted to win in the town he grew up in. After three races in downtown Nashville, it never happened.
The Colton Herta moved to Nashville in early 2023, and suddenly there were two IndyCar drivers living in Music City. When they announced that this year’s race was moving to Nashville Superspeedway, most figured if a local driver would win on the 1.33 mile oval east of downtown – it would be the one who dominated ovals in 2022-23, not the one that had never won an oval in his IndyCar career, and had just moved here.
I know Josef Newgarden has lost some fans along the way this season, and some of that is justified. But I would enjoy seeing the local driver that has lived here all of his life, come away with a hometown win before he hangs up his helmet. He has suddenly knocked down two Indianapolis 500 wins, so maybe he can check a Nashville win off of his list in the next year or so.
The Weather: As recently as Thursday, I was wondering if we would even see a car turn a wheel this weekend. The forecast for the remnants of Hurricane Francine, had the eye of the former hurricane stalling directly over Middle Tennessee for days. Some wondered if it might be Tuesday before we could crown a champion.
Saturday was a pleasant surprise. First we got in the full practice Saturday morning. Not only was it dry, it was even sunny. It was the same for qualifying on Saturday afternoon. Few at the track could believe our luck that we got so much in. The luck sort of ran out shortly after qualifying, as one of the circular bands went through – and then another, and another. At around 7:30 Saturday night, I finally gave up. But race officials stayed with track drying efforts and they finally got the final practice in.
Sunday dawned a beautiful day. There was not a cloud in the sky as I headed to the track, but shortly after I arrived and got settled, it started clouding up. By lunchtime, thew skies were gray and threatening. But they never opened up and by time for the race, it was sunny again. As I type on Sunday night, I have not seen a raindrop all day. We got very lucky, considering what had been predicted for days.
The Crowd: Not only was everyone predicting poor weather all weekend, but an almost non-existent crowd was expected. Now, I’m not going to gloss over things and call it a near-sellout, but all things considered – I think everyone was pleasantly surprised by how many people actually showed up. Maybe there was a large last-minute walk-up crowd that saw the same clear skies I saw on Sunday morning.
Few people I talked to all last week even knew IndyCar was in town this weekend, much less settling the championship. But apparently enough people got the word.
With a tropical storm passing through, the Titans home-opener getting all of the headlines and potential ticket buyers, and the late decision to move the race to the oval – some feared the stands would consist of only friends and families of drivers and crew members. I took this photo during the second caution period, about halfway through the race. I figured that was a truly representative time for a grandstand photo of the crowd. As you can see, it was not a bad crowd at all.
It was big enough to build on for next year, when this event will be held over Labor Day weekend. My wish is that they run the season finale next season as a night race on Sunday night. That would be the number one improvement I would suggest for this event. Cars look so much better at night. They really pop under the lights. This event did not go away after 2008 due to attendance issues. It was poor track ownership and management, which have both changed. I always thought that the fans loved the cars under the lights back in those days. Anytime you can run Indy cars under the lights, that’s a good thing. You will probably hear more from me on this topic in the offseason.
Drive of the Day: Most of the time I will choose a driver who didn’t win the race, but had a good showing for this award. But for Sunday’s race, I am going with the race winner – Colton Herta. He started ninth and had a not so great qualifying effort. Not much was expected of Herta, since he had never won on an oval. But he hung in there all day and made his move at the front when it counted – aided by an unbelievable pass on Pato O’Ward for the lead with only four laps remaining. Not only did he get his first oval win, he has earned the Oilpressure.com Drive of the Day.
All in All: This was a fun weekend, despite the threatening weather and the fear of a small crowd. Neither happened. There was a lot of energy with this event. Scott Borchetta and his Big Machine Records did a phenomenal job to pull this off after changing directions in February. There were a couple of minor hiccups, that can be tweaked for next year; but overall this was a very good event. I imagine it will be even better next year. In all honesty, if this event stayed at the oval and never returned to the streets of downtown Nashville – I wouldn’t be upset. I’m an oval fan at heart and this was a very fun event to attend in person. Well done, Music City Grand Prix!
George Phillips
September 16, 2024 at 5:55 am
good job George. get well and get home, Susan. question: what is the Nashville equivalent of the IMS breaded tenderloin and did they serve it at the track?
September 16, 2024 at 6:10 am
Visitors to Nashville might say “Nashville Hot Chicken”, but no real locals eat that. That has become a thing in just the last couple of decades, and it is usually only eaten by transplants or tourists. Nashville is best known for an unusually large number of “Meat & 3s”, or meat and three vegetables restaurants. After all, Cracker Barrell was founded in Lebanon – just up the road from the oval. But that’s hard to replicate at a concession stand.
September 16, 2024 at 6:29 am
Thanks George for your 2024 season coverage.
Excellent as usual and here is hoping that you and Susan get home later today from the hospital.
As Matthew Lawrenson wrote yesterday now onto the silly season shenanigans. Always fun.
I’m hoping not too many ride buyers and wondered when AJFoyt Racing last announced their drivers for the following season prior to the last race of the previous. Bodes well.
September 16, 2024 at 7:51 am
Thank you George for chronicling another super year of IndyCar racing for us. I greatly appreciate your blog (been a loyal reader since January 2010). Very glad that Susan is doing well after her surgery.
I thought it was an entertaining race and was very pleased they went to the oval; hopefully it will remain on the schedule. NBC’s sign-off was very good/very professional. They devoted about 5 minutes to wishing the series well at the new network, and were appreciative of their 16? years of involvement with the series. Compared to when ABC/ESPN said good-bye, it was very gratifying.
Looking forward to next year!
September 16, 2024 at 9:35 am
Glad to hear Susan is doing well and prayers and best wishes for her recovery.
I thought it was pretty entertaining race overall, though it definitely became more competitive late. Nashville is a unique oval, and I thought that added some additional intrigue to the race. After the poorly-received races at Iowa (and, frankly, years of limited action to improve the “product” after poorly-received races), Indycar worked to find and indeed did find a solution to facilitate passing and action at the ovals. Gateway, Milwaukee, and Nashville all provided numbers of passes and amounts of action not seen at ovals outside of Indy or Texas in probably 5+ years. Big kudos to the series on that.
I was glad to see Herta pick up his first oval win, he looks like a legitimate championship contender once again, and probably will take the title one day if the Andretti team is up to the task too. I was also glad to see Newgarden finally find the podium in his home town, I know the races in Nashville mean a lot to him.
Above all, though, I was glad to see a race weekend of positives after this event spent so much time facing predicted gloom and doom. Between the move from downtown, the reintroduction of a long-unused track that was not famous for well-received races in its day, the Titans playing at the same time, the poor weather forecast, and even the turn 2 bump that had internet experts predicting costly and dangerous multi-car wrecks during the race, a lot of folks were expecting (some seemingly hoping for) a disaster on the track and at the gate. Not so! It was heartening.
September 16, 2024 at 11:11 am
I am having Indycar withdrawals already…. sigh….
But seriously, I thought it was a good race and season overall. I was concerned about the implementation of the hybrid system, but it seems that worked out okay. 2025 should be a good year for Indycar and I hope JHR picks up Conor Daly for a full time ride. He made a noticeable improvement to the team.
I also thought that the season was just about right with the extra oval to end the season. You are right about the night races. Indycars look so much better under the lights!
September 16, 2024 at 1:49 pm
Thanks George for all yours and Susan’s hard work this season. I appreciate your postings and the comments from my fellow IC fans. Please give my best to Susan and I hope she is already home.
I had forgotten how wonderful it is to end the season on an oval!
September 16, 2024 at 3:35 pm
You said Josef had lost some fans? I think he has lost a ton and I personally hope he never wins another race. Cheating was the worst thing he did but his treatment of the NBC reported in Milwaukee was horrible too. In my opinion, he is a good racer but a complete loser.