Who Has Had The Best Offseason?

The so-called silly season has all but wound down now. It is now to the point that only part-time rides are left and even some of them are being filled. There is still the seat for the non-oval races for the No.20 car, which is occupied by Ed Carpenter on the ovals. Then there is the future KVSH, which is the mystery for 2017. Other than that, the lineup for the Firestone Grand Prix of St. Petersburg seems pretty well set.

Now may be as good a time as any to look at each team and evaluate whether or not they improved, remained about the same or weakened their driver lineup for 2017.

Team Penske: On the surface, when you give up a former series champion and a two-time Indianapolis 500 winner for a driver with only three career wins; one might draw the conclusion that Team Penske downgraded over last year. But when you realize that Juan Montoya is forty-one and Josef Newgarden is still about ten days from his twenty-sixth birthday, you realize that Penske is banking on Newgarden’s potential more than Montoya’s experience. A closer look at the stat sheet reveals that both drivers had two wins in 2015 and one this past season. Newgarden drove injured for half the year and finished fourth in the points. Montoya was at full-strength and finished eighth, while his Penske teammates finished first, second and third in the championship. Upgrade

Chip Ganassi Racing: The entire four driver lineup from this past season remains intact for 2017. The big change at Ganassi is that they have left Chevrolet for Honda. I don’t think I’m too far off base to say that you probably need a Chevy engine/aero kit package if you want to win the championship; but you can certainly win the Indianapolis 500 with a Honda. The fact that such a strong team may benefit all other Honda teams is out there, but I‘m still of the opinion that the Chevy package will be more desirable at any track that is not the oval at Indianapolis or Pocono. Downgrade

Andretti Autosport: Ryan Hunter-Reay and Alexander Rossi are both Indianapolis 500 champions, while Hunter-Reay also has an IndyCar championship to his credit. Marco Andretti is, well…let’s assume he’ll have a better year in 2017, he was probably lucky to finish a forgettable sixteenth in points this past season.

The wild-card is the No.26 car; piloted last year by Carlos Muñoz and finishing tenth – higher than any other driver on the team. Lack of money forced Muñoz to seek other opportunities in the paddock, finally landing a paid ride in the famous No.14 at AJ Foyt Enterprises. In turn, the former driver at Foyt, Takuma Sato, eventually landed in the No.26 at Michael Andretti’s team. Sato is fast, but he crashes a lot. We’ll call this a wash. Even

Schmidt Peterson Motorsports: Last season, driver James Hinchcliffe was coming off of a long recovery from the injuries sustained in a practice crash at Indianapolis in May of 2015. His prognosis was good, but there was still uncertainty about his stamina. After the first two races where Hinch finished nineteenth and eighteenth respectively, his season improved immensely, culminating with winning the pole for the Indianapolis 500 and contending for the win the entire race.

The other uncertainty was his new teammate, Mikhail Aleshin, who had also been recovering from a horrific crash at Fontana in 2014, when he was also driving for SPM. Both drivers had strong second halves to the season. Hinchcliffe finished thirteenth and Aleshin fifteenth. Both drivers carry momentum into 2017. The only uncertainty at SPM is a possible third car in probably a part-time role. The momentum and continuity from last season tells me this team should have better results in 2017. Upgrade

AJ Foyt Enterprises: Two new drivers and a new engine manufacturer will be featured for this team that struggled last season. Carlos Muñoz has long proven he can contend to win at Indianapolis, and has been consistently fast at other tracks. Conor Daly is a fan-favorite who understands what it means to drive for the legendary AJ Foyt. Along with the expected rookie mistakes this past season, Daly also showed he can run up front and stay there. With the Chevy package all through the season, I expect this team to make big strides next season. Upgrade

Ed Carpenter Racing: One of the few remaining question marks of next season is regarding who will split time with Ed Carpenter in the car for the non-ovals. But the other question was answered last month when JR Hildebrand was tabbed to replace Josef Newgarden in the vacated No.21 car. Hildebrand is a solid choice and is who I was hoping would get the ride. But he has not been in a car fulltime since John Barnes unceremoniously kicked him to the curb two days after the 2013 Indianapolis 500. With no wins to his credit and replacing a driver with three wins in the past two seasons, and the uncertainty of which driver will be his part-time teammate, you’d have to say this is a downgrade – until he proves otherwise, which he is certainly capable of. Downgrade

Rahal Letterman Lanigan: Graham Rahal has had two stellar seasons, especially for a one-car team. He did have rookie Spencer Pigot as a teammate for three races, but is a part-time rookie teammate an asset or a liability. For 2017, Rahal gets veteran driver Oriol Servia as a teammate for at least the Indianapolis 500 and possibly more. It all depends on how much sponsorship can be found in the next few months.

With everything else being equal, trading Spencer Pigot for Oriol Servia is a definite plus for this team. Upgrade

Dale Coyne Racing: Last season, Dale Coyne had a fulltime rookie in Conor Daly in one car, and a revolving door for the other with rokkie RC Enerson, Luca Filippi and Gabby Chaves splitting time in the other. The results were predictably not good. For 2017, Coyne gets four-time series champion Sébastien Bourdais for one car and rookie Ed Jones in the other – both on a full-time basis. Upgrade

KVSH Racing: At this point, we don’t even know if this team, or derivative of it, will even answer the bell for 2017. One thing is certain, this much uncertainty in the offseason is certainly not good. And yes, I used certainly several times on purpose. Incomplete

So that’s five upgrades, two downgrades, one even and one incomplete among the nine fulltime teams in the Verizon IndyCar Series. Do the upgrades go straight to the top, while the downgrades fall straight to the bottom? Of course not, some downgrades may turn out for the best, while the upgrades may be minimal or not at all. And it’s all relative.

At this point, I still think the championship will be decided between Penske and Ganassi just as it has for the past few years. But if Ganassi is strong with the Honda engine, there is a good chance that Andretti and possibly Schmidt may be contenders also.

It looks to be an entertaining season. The best news? The green flag flies for the opening race in St. Petersburg, exactly three months from today.

George Phillips

10 Responses to “Who Has Had The Best Offseason?”

  1. I have never been all that excited about Carlos Munoz. That is, however, about to change as Munoz will pilot the 14 car and frankly, I’d like to see Ol’ A. J. get one more shot at the brass ring, whether it’s a 500, a championship, or both. Hopefully, their engineering will allow him to contend. All fans should sit up and take notice this season, because Super Tex won’t be around too much longer and he’s one of a kind.

    • Great post, Skip I agree the garage area at Indy will never be the same once our hero A.J. is gone.
      Let’s hope the team can put it together this coming season.

    • billytheskink Says:

      I will remain convinced that AJ Foyt is immortal until proven otherwise. He’s survived broken backs, shattered legs, riptides, lions, angry bees, having a bulldozer dropped on his head… He may well be the Highlander, heck, he grew up in and around The Heights neighborhood in Houston.

      • There is a small restaurant near the Milwaukee Mile track where racing folks like to eat breakfast. I was going to the track one morning and I noticed A.J. and his golf cart driver coming down the sidewalk from the restaurant toward Greenfield Ave. There is no stoplight there, but when folks driving by saw who was in the golf cart, it was like the parting of the Red Sea. Cars screeched to a halt and there was much honking, waving, and thumbs uppin’ as A.J. motored safely across the street toward the track. Only one A.J. and one’s enough.

  2. billytheskink Says:

    Penske took silly season’s most desired prize, so I’d have to give the award (such as it is) to them. The rest of the moves should also be quite interesting, though, especially how Ganassi and Foyt adapt to their new engine and aero partners.

  3. I think Penske could have some more growing pains this season as Josef may not be quick out of the box much like Simon was 2 seasons ago. Long term though, they are in nice shape. Ganassi puzzles me, I have to think that the 2 main drivers won’t be around 5 years from now and they have Charlie and Max out there who really don’t do much for me. Andretti is in decent shape, but I wish Marco would have moved on to the Herta side of the team, he needs a fresh start! Rossi, well, you will never convince me he is any better than Max Chilton other than that smart 500 win. If not for that I don’t think he would have survived Silly Season this year.

    I really think Foyt is the most improved in the offseason but will they utilize it?

  4. I agree about the upgrade at Foyt, however, Penske gets the prize with Newgarden.

  5. I was also hoping to see Marco under the Herta umbrella. Overall, I think the Andretti team would be better served this coming season if Michael would focus on IndyCar and spend less time and energy with the electric cars, Rally cars and such. He has admitted as much himself. I’ve often wondered if they ever got paid for the New Orleans deal.

  6. Foyt’s team clearly had the biggest upgrade from this past season. You’re spot on with the assessment of Conor, he can stay up front if he is able to get there.

    I still believe Munoz (like Aleshin) is very underrated. We know how good he is at Indy, and I don’t expect that to change, even with driving a Chevy. Having the preferred aero kits on the road/street courses makes me believe he can win next year.

    For these same reasons, I have to say that Andretti’s team was more of a downgrade than a wash. I agree with everything else.

  7. Racing Acid Says:

    On the subject of KVSH Racing… what a blow to lose Bourdais to Dale Coyne of all teams. Yes, DC is a popular team, but they are perennial backmarkers like Manor in F1. I think they could get Pierre Gasly, if Red Bull are determined to keep him race sharp, if he is called up to Toro Rosso in 2018 (he can’t race in GP2 next year because former champions are banned). F1 fans like me (I’m from Britain) like Indycar a lot, so it’ll be good to see Gasly adapt to heavier cars with more downforce. If they have sponsorship (obviously), Antonio Giovinazzi or Sergey Sirotkin may appear for KVSH or the 2nd seat at ECR. Out of the Indy Lights stars who lost to Ed Jones this year, Santiago Urrutia deserves his chance. What a talent he is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: